What Edge Ratings Are For
Every active ticket on Scratchers Edge gets an automatic label so you can scan the Browse tab and Best Bets and know at a glance what you're looking at. Until this week, there were four: BUY for good value, NEW for tickets still too fresh to judge, PASS for tickets whose top prize is already gone, and WATCH — the one we just retired.
What WATCH Actually Measured
WATCH wasn't about the top prize or the odds. It was gated entirely by how fast prizes were being claimed. A ticket qualified for BUY only if its remaining prize pool was shrinking slowly — 2% or less per week. Cross that threshold, or lack enough snapshot history to measure a trend at all, and the ticket got bumped to WATCH instead, regardless of whether the top prize was still sitting there untouched.
The Ticket That Exposed the Problem
A reader asked us to look at Poker Night, a $10 OLG ticket that's been on shelves since mid-April. The numbers on it are good by any normal measure:
That decline works out to roughly 5.5% of the remaining pool disappearing every week, steadily, for the entire time we've tracked it — not a one-time spike, just a consistently popular ticket. Because 5.5% is well above our 2%-per-week cutoff, Poker Night was mathematically locked into WATCH forever. It could never earn BUY no matter how long the top prize stayed unclaimed, simply because people kept buying and winning on it at a steady clip.
⚠️ That's backwards. A ticket with its jackpot still alive after three months of steady play isn't a ticket to sit back and "watch." If anything, brisk depletion with the top prize still live is a reason to buy sooner, not a reason to wait.
Why Depletion Speed Was the Wrong Signal
Depletion speed answers a different question than the one that actually matters when you're deciding whether to buy. How fast a prize pool is shrinking tells you how popular a ticket is. It doesn't tell you whether the odds are good for a ticket you buy today — that's a function of how many prizes are left relative to how many tickets are estimated to be left, which is exactly what our percent sold and odds multiplier numbers already measure on every ticket card. Those figures don't care whether the depletion that got you there happened over two weeks or two months.
Using raw depletion speed as a gate for BUY meant popular, fast-moving tickets with intact top prizes were punished, while slow, barely-selling tickets got waved through — the opposite of what a value signal should reward.
What Changed, as of Today
Effective July 14, 2026, across all four regions (WCLC, BCLC, OLG, and Loto-Québec), the rating system is down to three labels:
- BUY — top prize still available, and the ticket has enough history to judge (not brand new).
- NEW — released within the last 60 days, or not enough snapshot data yet.
- PASS — top prize already claimed. Skip it.
Poker Night, and every ticket like it, now correctly shows BUY. The per-ticket depletion trend (fast, slow, stable) is still shown for context on the ticket card and trend chart — it just no longer decides whether a ticket clears the bar.
💡 Why we're posting this: Scratchers Edge only works if the ratings on it mean something. When a reader flags a case where the logic clearly gets it wrong — like Poker Night getting stuck at WATCH indefinitely — the right move is to fix the rule, not defend it. We'll keep writing these up when it happens.
What Doesn't Change
Nothing about how percent sold, odds multiplier, or prize counts are calculated has changed. Those numbers were never affected by this issue and remain the most reliable read on whether a specific ticket is worth buying right now.
Smart Picks scores every active scratch ticket across WCLC, BCLC, OLG & Loto-Québec by remaining prize money — so you know the best-value tickets before you buy. Updated daily.
Start Free Trial